BARTLEY COUSINS TWO
from
Thomas Bartley & Elizabeth Benny
and
Thomas Bartley & Mary Benney


     The second set of Bartley family cousins are from our 6th Great Grandfather Thomas Bartley and his wife Mary Benney through whom we descend. But there are two Thomas Bartleys about and though they are cousins themselves, only one of them fit in at this juncture. Yet there is some question as to where the one family ends and the other family begins as to their children. The last two children are known to be the children of Mary [Benney] Bartley for the parish record states them to be the children of Thomas and Mary Bartley. And the first child of the listing, William must be from Thomas Bartley and his wife Elizabeth becuase they are married the year prior to his birth and the other Thomas and Mary are not even married yet. So that child can be sorted out to him and his descendant cousins of ours left to another page's coverage. On the one hand they are all related but exactly where the two families are to be parted into two is the question. This is also the likelihood that the currect parish information is not complete and both seem to have gaps in the regular birthing expectancy. One asumption is that both William and Thomas are brothers of the same family as they are both married in Colon. From the north coast of Cornwal and St Columb Minor, Hannibal will actually find his wife Mary Henna and marry her on the south coast in Gorran. Whether that means he family or just him travels there and those details are not currently known. As to the two Mary Bartleys, if they are just one of the families, the first born would seem to have likely died but currently there is no burial record found for her in the required time frame before the other Mary's birth. There is one burial/death record for a Mary Bartley, the daughter of Thomas Bartley dated 1717, but for which Mary is the question. No marrage fit can be found for a Mary Bartley in this region and surname either. So some things are known and other things are not. But I need to dispaly the cousin relations on the one page or the other. So what I will do is I'll leave William and Thomas to where the Thomas Barley son of William Bartley fits in. And I will attempt to identify as much of the family of Thomas Robarts and Prudence Bartley as I can as cousins on this page. That family seems to travel and likely only some of their actual children will be found.


                                      William Bartley        Hannibal Bartley
                                            |                       |
                                            |                       |
              Elizabeth Benny    =    Thomas Bartley         Thomas Bartley*   =    Mary Benney
              cb 1 Oct 1665      |    cb 9 Apr 1667          cb 12 Nov 1673    |    cb 16 Feb 1677
                Newlyn East      |      St Columb Mnr          St Columb Mnr   |     St Columb Mnr
              m 7 Oct 1696       |                                             |    m 28 Dec 1698
               St Columb Mnr     |                                             |     St Columb Mnr
              d Apr 1732         |                                             |
              bur 18 Apr 1732    |                                             |
                St Columb Mnr    |                                             |
              (wife of Thomas)   |                                             |
          _______________________| _?_?_  ________?____________?____?__________|_____________
         |               |               |                |                 |                |
  William Bartley  Mary Bartley    Thomas Bartley  Prudence Bartley  Hannabal Bartley  Mary Bartley
                   b 1698
  cb 1 May 1697    cb 21 Jul 1700  cb 5 Nov 1700   cb 7 Mar 1702     cb 10 Mar 1705   cb 23 May 1711
   St Columb Mnr    St Columb Mnr   St Columb Mnr   St Columb Mnr     St Columb Mnr    St Columb Mnr
  m 27 Aug 1731    d bt 1700-1710  m 31 Oct 1734   m 9 Jan 1722      m 20 Feb 1731    d 1717?
    Colon          d 1717??          Colon           St Columb Mnr     Gorran         bur 2 Jul 1717
  = Prudence Giles                 = Jahon         = Thomas Robarts  = Mary Henna      St Columb Mnr
                                     Tribilcock


Thomas Robarts and Prudence Bartley Family of Cousins


The only children placed with this couple are those who state parentage as being of Thomas and Prudance (variously spelt). Other children at other locations cannot be for sure placed in this family with just the father being named as 'Thomas'.

                                 Thomas Robarts*   =    Prudence Bartley
                                 cb 21 Apr 1701    |    cb 7 Mar 1702
                                   St Columb Mnr   |      St Columb Mnr
                                 m 9 Jan 1722      |
                                  St Columb Mnr    |
                                 d Sep 1777?       |   d Sep 1788?
                                 bur 10 Sep 1777   |   bur 11 Sep 1788
                                   Newlyn East     |    Just in Penwith
          _________________________________________|_________________________________
         |                   |                  |                 |                  |  
    John Roberts      Charles Roberts    William Robarts     Mary Robarts       Amy Roberts
    cb 9 Mar 1726     cb 2 Nov 1729      cb 30 May 1732      cb 13 May 1735     cb 27 Aug 1744
      Newlyn East       Newlyn East        Newlyn East         Newlyn East        St Erme
                                                                                  (see below)


* There is a second Thomas Robarts buried 1787. Though there is some question as to applicable 
burial dates, they are what can be found currently whether they be or not, they are what is.
The name of Amy Roberts in St Erme is reasonably nearby even though the age gap would have to 
suggest a distant family 'caboose'. John and Charles fit well time wise with a possible phonetic 
spelling difference. As stated before, they all have Thomas and Prudence listed as their parents.

An added note: Ancestry.com, which posts word of mouth type information without a lot of 
source evidence, lists Prudence Bartley as marrying 'Thomas Roberts' so that 
was not from the parish marriage record. The suggest 8 children to this family (all 'Roberts')
of which are the five which I have plus three more, Thomas Roberts, Margery Roberts and a 
Prudence Roberts. Only two of those eight have any associated dates, William Roberts (1731-?)
and Amey Roberts (1740-1816). They do have the father Thomas Roberts born in 
St Newlyn (1698-1783). And of course Predence Bartley as (1702-?) but they say she was also 
born in St Newlyn rather than St Columb Minor where her parish baptism is recorded. They don't
have Prudence's or Thomas's parents. Perhaps with this 'reliable?' word of mouth and the actual 
source records, someone can proceed to do further research on this family and they may even 
find out that Purdence's father is Thomas Bartley. Ancestry.com is worth a look and can give 
some leads. I have yet to find it 100% accurate and fully solid in the source document department
and with my own Hender ancestry they continue to post numerous errors.
(see:@http://records.ancestry.com/prudence_bartley_records.ashx?pid=1970833)
There is a Thomas Robarts' baptism record in St Columb Minor of 21 April 1701, father Anthony 
Robarts. I find no Thomas 'Roberts' baptism record which would relate to a 1698 birth.
Amey ROBARTS did marry George JOHNS on 24 Jun 1768 at St 
Erme. William Robarts, her brother? was a witness, but no other confirming evidence as to
parentage is on the marriage record. Ancestry.com lists one child - Amey Johns and they date 
range her (1783-unknown)—her actual baptism record dates her baptism 24 May 1774
at St. Erme as Amey JOHNS Father: George and Mother: Amey.
(see @http://records.ancestry.com/amey_roberts_records.ashx?pid=45657478)
The St Erme parish also lists a sisters Prudence Johns (1769), Jinnifer Johns (1770), and Mary
Johns (1772). In Philleigh further siblings for George and Amey Johns are listed with their 
baptisms given - George (1776), William (1777), Robert (1779), Robert (1781), Mary (1782), 
Thomas (1784), Anne (1787) and Joey (1789) by which time poor mother Amey/Amy [Robarts] Johns 
would be age 44 (1789-1744=454) and with birthing 12 children. (see below)


George Johns and Amy/Amey Robarts Family



                                     George Johns    =    Amy/Amey Robarts/Roberts
                                     b a1732/33*     |    cb 27 Aug 1744
                                                     |      St Erme
                                     m 24 Jun 1768   |
                                       St Erme       |
                                     d Aug 1828 a95* |    d May 1816 age 72
                                     bur 10 Aug 1828 |    bur 18 May 1816
                                       Philleigh     |      Philleigh
                                   Residence Crantock|
  ___________________________________________________|___________________________________
 |        |               |            |               |                 |               |
 | Prudence Johns  Jinnifer Johns  Mary Johns      Amey Johns      George Johns    William Johns
 | cb 5 Jun 1769   cb 9 Oct 1770   cb 11 May 1772  cb 24 May 1774  cb 30 Jan 1776  cb 19 May 1777
 |   St Erme         St Erme         St Erme         St Erme         Philleigh       Philleigh
 |                                                 m 
 |
 |                                                 = John Hocking**
 |
 |
 |___________________________________________________________________________________
         |               |             |                 |            |              |
   Robert Johns    Robert Johns    Mary Johns      Thomas Johns   Anne Johns     Joey Johns
   cb 24 May 1779  cb 30 Jan 1781  cb 20 May 1782  cb 2 Aug 1784  cb 4 Jan 1787  cb 2 Nov 1789
     Philleigh       Philleigh       Philleigh       Philleigh      Philleigh      Philleigh
                                                                                   (daughter)


* According to parish source records Ancestry.com has George John's parentage wrong. He was NOT 
born in Crantock, Cornwall on 1738 to George Johns and Mary Davy. The fact is that his burial 
record states his age at death to be 95 (1828-92=1832/3). There are two possible baptisms which 
could fit this birth: cb 25 May 1732 at Helston, parents (Mr) George JOHNS and (Mrs) Bridget 
JOHNS. They were married at Helston 25 Jul 1717, George JOHNS and Bridget TREMENHEER (banns).
The other possible fit is cb 23 August 1732 at Madron George JOHNS son of Richard JOHNS. A note 
on this baptism states: At Penzance. While there are a number of marriage for Richard of 
this date range, perhaps the 'best' fit is at Crantock. Marriage date 17 Jan 1729 at Crantock
between Richard JOHNS and Margaret MARTIN. Richard Johns is stated as being resident of
St Agnes. As per the note on George Johns' burial record, which recorded his age at 95, it also 
stated that his residence was at Crantock. So I would suggest that his parentage 
is Richard Johns and Margaret Martin. That they may have been related to George Johns and Mary 
Davy of Crantock is quite possible as well.
** Ancestry.com reports that Amey Johns married John Hocking but gives not dates or place, 
neither is such found in the parish registers. 'Family Search' gives a marriage date of 30 
January 1806 to a Richard Hocking at Cornelly, Cornwall, England. There is a burial record for 
an Amey Hocking buried 11 July 1790 at Redruth, but that would be a reach. There are a number
of burials for  an Amy Hocking at a number of locations but no good fit. Perhaps she is out of
England?

There is a family for Richard Hocking and Amey Johns given next below:


Richard Hocking and Amey Johns Family


Father's occupation: Farmer. Residence: Beruppa in Ruan

                           Richard Hocking    =    Amey/Amy Johns
                                              |
                                              |
                           m 30 Jan 1806      |
                             Cornelly         |
                                              |
                                              |
            __________________________________|________________________________________
           |                   |                 |                 |                   |
      John Hocking       James Hocking    Emma Jane Hocking   Mary Hocking      Richard Hocking
      cb 20 Nov 1808*    cb 25 Feb 1810   cb 2 Jul 1812       cb 2 Jul 1815     cb 25 Jan 1816
       Ruan Lanihorne    Rual Lanihorne    Rual Lanihorne      Ruan Lanihorne    Ruan Lanihorne



*Privately baptised November 20, 1808, publically February 15 1809. And transcriber notes: 
'Richard crossed out, John inserted.

Whether or not that this all fits, it is here to be considered for what it is worth. And the source references are given in support of it rather than just listing names with no dates or documentation and claiming it to be so.